PlatPhorm Podcasts

Comment on Chiseled in Stone: Exploring Meanings of Confederate Statues in Virginia by Michael S. Kogan, Ph.D.

Comments for Virginia Public Radio · July 30, 2020

PlatPhorm Podcasts fallback artwork

episode · Playback unavailable

Comment on Chiseled in Stone: Exploring Meanings of Confederate Statues in Virginia by Michael S. Kogan, Ph.D.

Comments for Virginia Public Radio

The shameful removal of monuments honoring those men and boys who gave their lives to defend our Southland against the invader, reveals the ignorance of history that dominates this moment in time. The South acted, under the rights reserved for the states in the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution, to voluntarily withdraw from a voluntary Union the states had created. Secession was not treason. That is why Jefferson Davis was not tried for treason. The victorious Union knew they could never get a conviction. These were Southern men of honor who had no desire to overthrow the Federal Government, but only to leave in peace, which was their Constitutional right. The slavery issue as a motivation for the War was only invented in 1863, when Lincoln issued the totally ineffective "Emancipation Proclamation," which freed not a single slave, but transformed a war of aggression against the Southern states, into a war of liberation. This was a cynical political act with the sole purpose of keeping Great Britain from intervening on the Southern side. Today, the War, and virtually everything else, is seen through the narrow lens of "race." This single visioned distortion of history prevents the ignorant from understanding the complexities of both past and present, and has led to this orgy of vengeance and violence against our memorials to dead heroes. Prof. Michael S. Kogan, Ph.D.

View original

The shameful removal of monuments honoring those men and boys who gave their lives to defend our Southland against the invader, reveals the ignorance of history that dominates this moment in time. The South acted, under the rights reserved for the states in the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution, to voluntarily withdraw from a voluntary Union the states had created. Secession was not treason. That is why Jefferson Davis was not tried for treason. The victorious Union knew they could never get a conviction. These were Southern men of honor who had no desire to overthrow the Federal Government, but only to leave in peace, which was their Constitutional right. The slavery issue as a motivation for the War was only invented in 1863, when Lincoln issued the totally ineffective “Emancipation Proclamation,” which freed not a single slave, but transformed a war of aggression against the Southern states, into a war of liberation. This was a cynical political act with the sole purpose of keeping Great Britain from intervening on the Southern side. Today, the War, and virtually everything else, is seen through the narrow lens of “race.” This single visioned distortion of history prevents the ignorant from understanding the complexities of both past and present, and has led to this orgy of vengeance and violence against our memorials to dead heroes. Prof. Michael S. Kogan, Ph.D.

Published
July 30, 2020
Status
active
GUID hash
ab7106022b67d063221e83fc4869bd2dbd6a1ea6c19cf39fdeb202d4c39f05fe
Archive key
comment-on-chiseled-in-stone-exploring-meanings-of-confederate-statues-in-virginia-by-mich--entry_650e4705876ed885eb9f7c2593f3
Archive id
entry_650e4705876ed885eb9f7c2593f3